LEFT BEHIND NO. 10: Earl Williams


earl williams.jpgRighthanded Hitting, Righthanded Throwing C/1B/3B
Seasons with Braves: 1970-72, 1975-76
Career Stats with Braves: .251/.321/.437, 81 HR, 255 RBI, 200 RS

Earl Williams won Rookie of the Year for the Braves in 1971 by blasting 33 homers for America’s Team. He hit another 28 the next year, then was traded in a package for, among others, Pat Dobson, Davey Johnson, and Johnny Oates. The O’s sold him back to us for cash (a simpler time) two years later.

Again, kiddies, let’s put this in historical perspective. Thirty-three homers in 1971 is basically like 44 today. He finished fifth in the NL in homers that year, and his 28 were good enough for eighth in ’72. Johnny Bench had 67 total (led the league in 1973) in those same years to Earl’s 61. Thus, Earl’s taters were a lot of production from behind the plate. Only four NL teams in 1972 had catchers with double digit homers from their starting catcher. Earl’s 28 were a ton of dingers.

His defense was fairly solid: he was not cat-quick (back then that catcher model didn’t really exist) but he did have a strong arm. He eventually gravitated to first base by way of third base.

His 81 homers make him 18th on the list of Atlanta Braves. Every single person ahead of him is on Mac’s list, as are the two guys right behind him (Chris Chambliss and Dusty Baker).

Does he make the cut? Very, very close, but really — only if the 44 have to carry a third catcher. His Braves career wasn’t really long enough in my book. Sorry, Earl, missed it by THAT much.

Extra Commentary by Mac: Williams falls into the Brian Jordan trap. His first tenure with the Braves isn’t long enough for consideration, and his second tenure with the team is so bad that it drags his career down to below-average. His good years are offensively just as good as Torre’s and Lopez’s.

Earl Williams Statistics – Baseball-Reference.com

5 thoughts on “LEFT BEHIND NO. 10: Earl Williams”

  1. Some big named players filed for Free Agency today…

    Barry Bonds- LF/DH( I think he’s going to Oakland)
    Frank Thomas- 1B/DH
    Nomar Garciaparra- 1B
    Barry Zito- SP( Probably going to the Yanks or Mets)
    Alfonso Soriano- LF(I wonder if he plans to go back to 2B)
    Kerry Wood- SP
    Andy Pettitte- SP
    Roger Clemens- SP( I have a feeling he’ll be with the Red Sox)
    Luis Gonzalez- LF
    Cliff Floyd- LF
    Ricky Ledee- OF
    Orlando Hernandez- SP
    Steve Trachsel- SP
    Chris Woodward- IF
    Mike Lieberthal- C
    Arthur Rhodes- RP
    Rick White- RP
    Randy Wolf- SP
    Aaron Fultz- SP
    Octavio Dotel- RP( It would be nice if we could pick him up)
    Craig Wilson- OF/1B
    Miguel Cairo- IF


  2. I remember watching a game once as a little kid, must’ve been 1971 or 72, and Earl Williams hit a HR into the upper deck of Veterans Stadium in Philadelphia. A titanic blast.

    The next time up, Phils manager Frank Lucchesi asked the umps to check Williams’ bat. I remember Braves announcer Milo Hamilton saying, “I think they’re checking for metal, but I don’t think they’re gonna find any.”

  3. Hey sure could hit, but I think “solid” vastly overates his defense. Immobile would be a better description.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.